doi:10.12171/j.1000-1522.20220028
Effects of four banyan species on the growth, development and feeding preference ofPerina nuda
-
Key words:
- Perina nuda/
- Ficusspp./
- development period/
- survival rate/
- feeding preference
?nbsp; 1不同榕树对榕透翅毒蛾幼虫和蛹存活率的影响
1L?L?L?L?L?~8L分别?龄?龄?龄?龄?龄? ~ 8龄幼虫;PP. 蛹;TT. 总体。同组数据不同字母表示幼虫和蛹的存活率差异显著(P< 0.05)?L, 2L, 3L, 4L, 5L, and 6?L mean 1st instar, 2nd instar, 3rd instar, 4th instar, 5th instar and 6th?th instar, respectively; PP, pupa; TT, total. Different lowercase letters indicate significant differences in survival rates at larval and pupal stage between different banyan species (P< 0.05).
Figure 1.Effects of banyan species on the survival rates ofP. nudaduring larval and pupal stages
?nbsp; 2不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾幼虫体长
Table 2.Body length ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
发育阶段 Development stage |
体长 Body length/mm | 统计分析 Statistical analysis | ||||||
黄金F. microcarpa | 高山F. altissima | 小叶F. concinna | 垂叶F. benjamina | F | df | P | ||
2龄幼 2nd instar larva | 4.476 ± 0.076a | 4.087 ± 0.074b | 3.580 ± 0.105c | 3.921 ± 0.128b | 16.508 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
3龄幼 3rd instar larva | 5.959 ± 0.119a | 5.593 ± 0.216ab | 5.036 ± 0.312bc | 4.933 ± 0.181c | 5.261 | 3 | 0.002 | |
4龄幼 4th instar larva | 9.873 ± 0.303a | 7.789 ± 0.278b | 7.467 ± 0.368b | 6.440 ± 0.223c | 19.801 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
5龄幼 5th instar larva | 14.220 ± 0.531a | 9.524 ± 0.336ab | 11.120 ± 0.728ab | 8.122 ± 0.504c | 26.107 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
6龄幼 6th instar larva | 21.177 ± 0.654a | 14.276 ± 0.626ab | 13.783 ± 0.729ab | 10.560 ± 0.531c | 40.018 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
7龄幼 7th instar larva | 22.300 ± 1.944a | 19.536 ± 0.825ab | 17.300 ± 1.093bc | 14.850 ± 1.017c | 6.648 | 3 | 0.001 | |
8龄幼 8th instar larva | 18.433 ± 1.323 |
?nbsp; 3不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾幼虫体质野/p>
Table 3.Mass ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
发育阶段 Development stage |
体质 Body mass/g | 统计分析 Statistical analysis | ||||||
黄金F. microcarpa | 高山F. altissima | 小叶F. concinna | 垂叶F. benjamina | F | df | P | ||
2龄幼 2nd instar larva | 0.001 5 ± 0.000 1a | 0.001 1 ± 0.000 1b | 0.001 0 ± 0.000 1bc | 0.000 8 ± 0.000 10c | 16.521 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
3龄幼 3rd instar larva | 0.005 1 ± 0.000 2a | 0.003 2 ± 0.000 2b | 0.002 6 ± 0.000 3bc | 0.002 2 ± 0.000 2c | 33.36 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
4龄幼 4th instar larva | 0.016 9 ± 0.001 0a | 0.009 1 ± 0.000 6b | 0.008 9 ± 0.001 9b | 0.005 4 ± 0.000 5c | 21.877 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
5龄幼 5th instar larva | 0.059 9 ± 0.004 8a | 0.023 3 ± 0.001 7b | 0.025 4 ± 0.005 2b | 0.012 2 ± 0.001 7b | 27.684 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
6龄幼 6th instar larva | 0.187 6 ± 0.141 9a | 0.086 6 ± 0.007 9b | 0.064 0 ± 0.013 1bc | 0.031 2 ± 0.005 4c | 30.315 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
7龄幼 7th instar larva | 0.216 9 ± 0.021 9a | 0.174 3 ± 0.016 0ab | 0.122 4 ± 0.015 5bc | 0.087 8 ± 0.015 3c | 8.198 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
8龄幼 8th instar larva | 0.139 9 ± 0.022 6 |
?nbsp; 4不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾幼虫排泄物质野/p>
Table 4.Fecal mass ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
发育阶段 Development stage |
粪质 Fecal mass/g | 统计分析 Statistical analysis | ||||||
黄金F. microcarpa | 高山F. altissima | 小叶F. concinna | 垂叶F. benjamina | F | df | P | ||
2龄幼 2nd instar larva | 0.006 9 ± 0.000 4a | 0.006 9 ± 0.000 6a | 0.006 3 ± 0.001 1a | 0.003 2 ± 0.000 2b | 7.268 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
3龄幼 3rd instar larva | 0.030 0 ± 0.002 5a | 0.016 3 ± 0.001 1b | 0.020 3 ± 0.005 2b | 0.007 0 ± 0.000 7c | 12.374 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
4龄幼 4th instar larva | 0.124 9 ± 0.014 2a | 0.062 2 ± 0.005 9b | 0.069 6 ± 0.017 5b | 0.020 9 ± 0.003 7c | 10.628 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
5龄幼 5th instar larva | 0.563 8 ± 0.055 6a | 0.264 2 ± 0.033 4b | 0.238 0 ± 0.073 4b | 0.062 0 ± 0.008 9c | 15.075 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
6龄幼 6th instar larva | 2.231 3 ± 0.237 4a | 1.418 0 ± 0.191 3a | 1.784 4 ± 0.601 8a | 0.237 1 ± 0.055 4b | 7.335 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
7龄幼 7th instar larva | 4.139 3 ± 0.368 5a | 2.922 6 ± 0.277 3a | 3.781 4 ± 0.587 9a | 0.994 7 ± 0.276 8b | 11.104 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
8龄幼 8th instar larva | 1.918 1 ± 0.369 8 | |||||||
幼虫 Larval stage | 3.504 7 ± 0.267 1b | 3.530 4 ± 0.219 7b | 5.288 9 ± 0.457 1a | 2.668 9 ± 0.263 4b | 8.401 | 3 | < 0.001 |
?nbsp; 5不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾幼虫头壳宽度
Table 5.Head capsule width ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
发育阶段 Development stage |
头壳 Head capsule width/mm | 统计分析 Statistical analysis | ||||||
黄金F. microcarpa | 高山F. altissima | 小叶F. concinna | 垂叶F. benjamina | F | df | P | ||
1龄幼 1st instar larva | 0.463 3 ± 0.002 4c | 0.472 9 ± 0.002 1a | 0.464 5 ± 0.002 7bc | 0.470 8 ± 0.001 9ab | 4.581 | 3 | 0.006 | |
2龄幼 2nd instar larva | 0.682 4 ± 0.005 9a | 0.661 5 ± 0.004 5ab | 0.656 3 ± 0.025 9ab | 0.647 0 ± 0.129 2b | 3.236 | 3 | 0.028 | |
3龄幼 3rd instar larva | 1.105 5 ± 0.0173a | 0.925 4 ± 0.019 0c | 1.019 5 ± 0.062 6b | 0.889 0 ± 0.023 0c | 14.315 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
4龄幼 4th instar larva | 1.674 7 ± 0.033 0a | 1.423 4 ± 0.027 7b | 1.443 6 ± 0.099 0b | 1.245 4 ± 0.070 8c | 13.987 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
5龄幼 5th instar larva | 2.463 6 ± 0.055 5a | 2.053 6 ± 0.045 3b | 1.972 8 ± 0.119 3b | 1.583 4 ± 0.082 0c | 23.507 | 3 | < 0.001 | |
6龄幼 6th instar larva | 2.797 5 ± 0.1181a | 2.656 4 ± 0.047 9ab | 2.432 9 ± 0.113 3bc | 2.232 2 ± 0.122 8c | 5.804 | 3 | 0.003 | |
7龄幼 7th instar larva | 3.270 7 ± 0.059 0a | 2.999 5 ± 0.037 7b | 2.855 7 ± 0.049 7bc | 2.739 3 ± 0.132 7c | 9.498 | 3 | < 0.001 |
?nbsp; 6不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾幼虫头壳宽度回归方程
Table 6.Regression equation and coefficient of determination of head capsule width ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
寄主 Host | 回归方程 Regression equation | R2 |
黄金F. microcarpa | y= 0.004x6 0.091 8x5+ 0.819 7x4 3.645 5x3+ 8.536 9x2 9.574 8x+ 4.414 9 | 0.969 7 |
高山F. altissima | y= 0.000 8x5 0.021 2x4+ 0.181 6x3 0.593 4x2+ 0.987 4x 0.082 2 | 0.970 6 |
小叶榔i>F. concinna | y= 0.001 1x6 0.026 7x5+ 0.249 3x4 1.170 8x3+ 2.940 6x2 3.417 7x+ 1.888 6 | 0.907 6 |
垂叶F. benjamina | y= 0.000 3x6 0.009 7x5+ 0.109 2x4 0.590 3x3+ 1.643 5x2 1.986 1x+ 1.304 7 | 0.936 6 |
注:x. 龄期:i>y. 头壳宽度。Notes:x, instar;y, head capsule width. |
?nbsp; 7不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾蛹的质量
Table 7.Pupal mass ofP. nudaat larval stages reared by different banyan species
性别 Sex | 蛹质 Pupal mass/g | 统计分析 Statistical analysis | ||||||
黄金F. microcarpa | 高山F. altissima | 小叶F. concinna | 垂叶F. benjamina | F | df | P | ||
雌虫 Female worm | 0.254 0 ± 0.015 9a | 0.230 9 ± 0.012 1ab | 0.207 3 ± 0.008 1b | 0.232 1 ± 0.018 6ab | 2.489 | 3 | 0.076 | |
雄虫 Male worm | 0.157 1 ± 0.005 4a | 0.138 4 ± 0.005 8bc | 0.130 6 ± 0.003 5c | 0.152 2 ± 0.003 3ab | 5.360 | 3 | 0.004 | |
总体 Total | 0.219 4 ± 0.016 4a | 0.184 7 ± 0.012 0ab | 0.161 8 ± 0.007 8b | 0.195 8 ± 0.016 0ab | 4.262 | 3 | 0.008 |
?nbsp; 8不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾成虫寿命、预卵期和产卵量
Table 8.Adult longevity, pre-ovulation period and egg production ofP. nudareared by different banyan species
寄主 Host | 雌虫寿命 Female worm longevity/d |
雄虫寿命 Male worm longevity/d |
预卵朞br/> Pre-ovulation period/d | 产卵野br/> Egg production |
黄金F. microcarpa | 11.13 ± 0.99a | 8.83 ± 1.05ab | 3.87 ± 0.46a | 182.13 ± 18.22ab |
高山F. altissima | 9.54 ± 0.42a | 10.07 ± 0.41a | 3.21 ± 0.47a | 226.14 ± 30.05a |
小叶F. concinna | 9.71 ± 0.68a | 7.20 ± 0.58b | 3.80 ± 1.02a | 107.43 ± 32.94bc |
垂叶F. benjamina | 9.60 ± 0.60a | 8.25 ± 0.63ab | 4.50 ± 0.50a | 85.00 ± 40.52c |
统计分析 Statistical analysis | F= 0.972,P= 0.416 | F= 3.823,P= 0.022 | F= 0.664,P= 0.580 | F= 4.326,P= 0.010 |
注:同一列数据不同小写字母表示差异显著(P< 0.05)。同?~12。Notes: different lowercase letters in the same column of data indicate significant differences (P< 0.05). Same as Tab. 9?2. |
?nbsp; 9不同榕树饲养的榕透翅毒蛾第二代卵历期和孵化率
Table 9.Incubation period and hatching rate of the second generation ofP. nudareared by different banyan species
寄主 Host | 卵历 Incubation period/d | 孵化率Hatching rate/% |
黄金F. microcarpa | 8.40 ± 0.245a | 60.358 0 ± 5.982a |
高山F. altissima | 9.17 ± 0.477a | 59.643 3 ± 8.104a |
小叶F. concinna | 8.33 ± 0.333a | 49.786 7 ± 16.300a |
垂叶F. benjamina | 8.80 ± 0.374a | 51.605 0 ± 15.942a |
统计分析 Statistical analysis | F= 0.950,P= 0.442 | F= 0.442,P= 0.872 |
?nbsp; 10取食经历对榕透翅毒蛾5龄幼虫不同寄?20 min取食量的影响
Table 10.Effects of feeding experience on 120 min feeding intake of the 5th instar larvae ofP. nuda
5龄幼虫取食寄为br/> 5th instar larval feeding host | 1 ~ 4龄取食黄金榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. microcarpa |
1 ~ 4龄取食高山榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. altissima |
1 ~ 4龄取食小叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. concinna |
1 ~ 4龄取食垂叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. benjamina |
总体 Total |
黄金榔br/>F. microcarpa | 0.004 2 ± 0.001 9b | 0.005 1 ± 0.002 9a | 0.002 7 ± 0.000 7a | 0.011 8 ± 0.005 6a | 0.005 9 ± 0.001 7a |
高山榔br/>F. altissima | 0.019 6 ± 0.001 5a | 0.006 4 ± 0.002 2a | 0.002 3 ± 0.001 2a | 0.003 4 ± 0.001 0a | 0.008 4 ± 0.001 9a |
小叶榔br/>F. concinna | 0.004 1 ± 0.002 1b | 0.005 1 ± 0.001 7a | 0.008 2 ± 0.002 8a | 0.010 9 ± 0.000 2a | 0.006 5 ± 0.001 1a |
垂叶榔br/>F. benjamina | 0.009 6 ± 0.005 3b | 0.000 9 ± 0.000 5a | 0.003 7 ± 0.002 6a | 0.008 5 ± 0.000 8a | 0.006 0 ± 0.001 3a |
P | < 0.001 | 0.422 | 0.170 | 0.368 | 0.629 |
?nbsp; 11取食经历对榕透翅毒蛾5龄幼?20 min相对摄入指数的影哌/p>
Table 11.Effects of feeding experience on the 120 min relative ingestion index of the 5th instar larvae ofP. nuda
5龄幼虫取食寄为br/> 5th instar larval feeding host | 1 ~ 4龄取食黄金榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. microcarpa |
1 ~ 4龄取食高山榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. altissima |
1 ~ 4龄取食小叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. concinna |
1 ~ 4龄取食垂叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. benjamina |
总体 Total |
黄金榔br/>F. microcarpa | 0.103 8 ± 0.019 2b | 0.094 0 ± 0.040 3a | 0.109 8 ± 0.022 2a | 0.180 7 ± 0.123 9a | 0.122 1 ± 0.031 1a |
高山榔br/>F. altissima | 0.169 8 ± 0.015 0a | 0.123 3 ± 0.022 5a | 0.107 5 ± 0.038 3a | 0.084 0 ± 0.017 6a | 0.125 3 ± 0.014 3a |
小叶榔br/>F. concinna | 0.065 8 ± 0.014 4b | 0.161 9 ± 0.029 5a | 0.103 0 ± 0.034 6a | 0.059 4 ± 0.016 4a | 0.101 7 ± 0.015 8a |
垂叶榔br/>F. benjamina | 0.101 4 ± 0.012 5b | 0.090 5 ± 0.038 2a | 0.126 0 ± 0.033 7a | 0.055 6 ± 0.009 3a | 0.093 6 ± 0.013 0a |
P | 0.002 | 0.386 | 0.968 | 0.574 | 0.614 |
?nbsp; 12取食经历对榕透翅毒蛾5龄幼?20 min取食面积的影哌/p>
Table 12.Effects of feeding experience on the 120 min feeding area of the 5th instar larvae ofP. nuda
5龄幼虫取食寄 5th instar larval feeding host |
1 ~ 4龄取食黄金榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. microcarpa |
1 ~ 4龄取食高山榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. altissima |
1 ~ 4龄取食小叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. concinna |
1 ~ 4龄取食垂叶榕幼虫 1st to 4th instar larva reared byF. benjamina |
总体 Total |
黄金 F. microcarpa |
0.470 8 ± 0.057 3b | 0.237 9 ± 0.096 0a | 0.182 1 ± 0.065 5a | 0.045 4 ± 0.004 1a | 0.234 1 ± 0.049 1a |
高山 F. altissima |
0.949 3 ± 0.092 0a | 0.181 1 ± 0.046 9a | 0.133 9 ± 0.027 7a | 0.032 1 ± 0.004 3a | 0.356 5 ± 0.094 0a |
小叶 F. concinna |
0.407 9 ± 0.111 4b | 0.132 8 ± 0.041 0a | 0.176 4 ± 0.056 8a | 0.073 6 ± 0.026 9a | 0.213 5 ± 0.047 4a |
垂叶 F. benjamina |
0.926 1 ± 0.143 4a | 0.195 7 ± 0.066 0a | 0.196 9 ± 0.095 3a | 0.067 5 ± 0.020 6a | 0.356 6 ± 0.102 3a |
P | 0.003 | 0.683 | 0.891 | 0.347 | 0.397 |